Select Page

From Ganges Delta to Wuhan: The stigma of naming diseases after their place of origin

By Mari Webel, Assistant Professor of History, University of Pittsburgh

Stop calling the novel coronavirus outbreak the “Wuhan coronavirus,” and start getting comfortable with “COVID-19.” That is the World Health Organization’s recommended name for the disease.

While identifying a new disease by its place of origin seems intuitive, history demonstrates that doing so can harm the people who live there. Consequences can include economic distress, as tourists withdraw, investment cools down and solidarities between people weaken. Linking a specific disease with a specific place can lead to discrimination and stigmatization and avoidance of a town or village.

As a historian of public health and modern Africa, I study the politics of infectious diseases and the importance of understanding the cultural contexts of epidemics and responses to them. Past epidemics underscore the social and public health consequences of how people talk about a disease’s origins.

A long tradition of naming by place

Tagging a place when identifying a disease has a long history. In the 19th century, as global trade and mobility allowed cholera to spread worldwide from its origins in the Ganges Delta, the disease quickly became known as “the Asiatic cholera.” That label persisted for decades, implicitly blaming an entire continent for a disease that can spread anywhere as a function of poor sanitation.

For Europeans and Americans of the time, Asia was an exotic, distant somewhere else. Distinguishing the disastrous illness of cholera as “Asiatic” fit with the racialized, imperial views that denigrated the intelligence and the cultures of non-white populations globally and justified colonial overrule. It also helped justify more stringent quarantine measures and travel restrictions for people read as “Asian” and not European. Muslim pilgrims en route to Mecca from southern Asia, for instance, were subject to different rules than European troop ships traveling the same routes.

Ideas about disease changed after the late 19th century, when scientists could use new laboratory techniques to link specific pathogens – bacteria, parasites, and later on, viruses – to specific diseases. Sometimes, this gave a scientific name to an age-old problem, such as “consumption” becoming the medical entity tuberculosis.

But these new techniques also allowed researchers to correlate pathogens with particular locales. Naming an illness after a place quickly became the norm. So Rift Valley Fever, caused by a virus in the Bunyaviridae family, got its name from an area of colonial Kenya where it was first reported. The Hantaviruses are linked to the Hantan River area of South Korea where Dr. Ho-Wang Lee first identified the virus.

Ebola virus disease (EVD) got its popular name from a river near the village in the modern nation of Democratic Republic of Congo (formerly Zaïre) where U.S. and European scientists identified that pathogen.

Focusing on a specific place creates something particular from something that could have happened anywhere. There’s nothing peculiarly distinctive about Lassa village in Nigeria, compared to any other village five or 50 miles away. Lassa was just the first place where a white missionary’s death drew the attention of authorities. And yet, in the aftermath of that moment, as “Lassa fever” came to identify a fearsome hemorrhagic fever, the town of Lassa became a shadow of its former self.

Focusing on the wrong things

In the short term, close associations between places and diseases can stigmatize the sick, as well as influence perceptions of risk for people both nearby and distant. An outbreak of a serious and deadly respiratory and hemorrhagic disease reported in the U.S.’ Four Corners region in 1993 was tagged by the press as a “Navajo flu.” People in the area assumed incorrectly that the disease was directly contagious and highly localized to the Navajo Nation.

Associating this alarming new disease specifically with the Navajo Nation had a chilling effect on reporting illness to medical authorities because of fear of stigma. In the end, officials named the new hantavirus that caused that particular outbreak Sin Nombre, which means “without a name” in Spanish.

Understanding disease ecology and patterns of transmission at a point of origin are important for biologists and epidemiologists. But permanently naming a disease for a specific place serves to keep public attention on the moment of origin – the “spillover” case or known outbreak of an epidemic.

Focusing on how an “emerging” disease originally reached human populations can come at the expense of clear messaging about who is at risk of infection or how to prevent the disease in an ongoing epidemic. What’s more, that outbreak moment is often less relevant for a general public looking to stay healthy or public health practitioners trying to control a person-to-person epidemic.

Building blame into a name

Affixing place to disease also puts a spotlight on specific people, which matters for how a wider public associates a population’s perceived culture, foodways or activities with a disease. These kinds of stereotypes arose, for instance, around Ebola virus disease in 2014-15, erroneously blaming some people for a wider problem. Early conversations about EVD, marked as particularly African with its name, focused on eating “bushmeat,” a term from the colonial era to describe meat that people hunt, rather than buy in a market.

Talking about “bushmeat” allowed people to characterize those suffering from EVD as primitive or exotic. It also implied that people were responsible for bringing this disease into circulation because of what they ate or how they lived. In fact, the wider spread of EVD in 2014-15 had everything to do with underfunded health systems in the affected nations and nothing to do with what people ate.

A similar process is unfolding now, with rumors that Wuhan’s “wet markets” are the culprits of zoonotic spillover, where viruses jump from animals to humans. Scientists don’t yet know how relevant Wuhan’s live-animal markets truly were for this global epidemic, although they do know that viruses jump from animals to humans (and back again) frequently. Wuhan’s historic position as a national high-speed rail and commercial hub is likely to be far more important for the wider dissemination of COVID-19 than where and how people shopped and ate.

Get used to COVID-19

Public health officials and scientists have come to understand the potentially harmful repercussions of associating place and disease names – for both the immediate public health response and the long-term economic and social future of a given place. In 2015 WHO announced its official guidelines to avoid the practice.

In the past weeks, as the novel coronavirus has dominated the news and spread around the world, there’s been vigorous debate about what to call it. It’s important for both a popular understanding of risk and prevention, as well as for global solidarity with the heavily affected population of Wuhan, to get used to saying “COVID-19” and to insist that others do the same.

After all, Spain had nothing specific to do with the so-called “Spanish influenza,” as the devastating H1N1 influenza pandemic of 1918-19 was popularly known for decades. They just reported it first.

Support evidence-based journalism with a tax-deductible donation today, make a contribution to The Conversation.

  1. Coronavirus chaos on historic election day creates challenges for Milwaukee voters
  2. Passenger overcrowding forces MCTS to limit 10 riders per bus for health safety beginning April 9
  3. “Moment at the Museum” video series provides online tour of historic exhibit for Milwaukee public
  4. Sofa Cinema: Milwaukee Film launches virtual movie portal for home theaters
  5. Milwaukee Rep brings its creative performances and activities “From Our Home to Your Home”
  6. Democracy or Death: State GOP forces a smash-and-grab election with in-person voting during a pandemic
  7. Entitlement to Govern: How the fog of pandemic offers one more chance for a power grab
  8. Institutional Betrayal: The lasting trauma from playing down the threat of COVID-19 and failing to act
  9. Officials ask Milwaukee consumers to report fraudulent claims related to coronavirus crisis
  10. President Thanos: Trump’s genocidal intentions were foreshadowed in his re-election campaign video
  11. Citizen solders and airmen from Wisconsin National Guard assist with state’s COVID-19 response
  12. State National Guard units are taking the lead in the military’s response to the coronavirus
  13. Unfounded conspiracy theories force Wisconsin National Guard to debunk enforcement rumors
  14. U.S. Navy fires captain of aircraft carrier who sought help for his sailors stricken with COVID-19
  15. News outlets warned for months about the coronavirus but few listened
  16. Life goes on even when it doesn’t: Streaming a funeral “watch party” in the age of coronavirus
  17. Fear of The Walking Dumb: The health of our nation is being decimated by willful ignorance
  18. By The Numbers: Tracking the impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic sweeping across Wisconsin
  19. Politics over Humanity: Wisconsin GOP seeks to rig latest election through attrition of urban voters
  20. Milwaukee leaders explore using Wisconsin State Fair grounds as overflow facility for COVID-19 patients
  21. Milwaukee COVID-19 survivor shares personal medical experience via social media to educate others
  22. Regional banks and city leadership plan cooperative efforts to address Milwaukee's economic challenges
  23. Governor Tony Evers calls for special session to delay primary but Lawmakers insist election proceed
  24. Milwaukee faces poll worker shortage for April 7 election amid pandemic complications
  25. Protecting the Democracy: How to ensure safe elections amid the coronavirus pandemic
  26. Reggie Jackson: The next challenge of the COVID-19 fight in Milwaukee
  27. Already a community infected by racial hate, Anti-Asian sentiment hits Milwaukee along with COVID-19
  28. Building Community Bridges to Improve Health Equity in the COVID-19 Era and Beyond
  29. GoFundMe campaign raises funds to buy meals for frontline hospital workers from local restaurants
  30. A crisis within a crisis: COVID-19 disproportionally impacts Milwaukee’s black neighborhoods
  31. Public health concerns push Milwaukee’s 2020 Democratic National Convention to August
  32. Reggie Jackson: Critical lessons we need to learn about COVID-19 from China and Italy
  33. Sorry, some of you have to die: A Conservative Christian plan to save the economy
  34. A wake-up call for humanity: The coronavirus pandemic exposes long ignored failures of our society
  35. Fear of demographic change has increased White Nationalist hate groups 55% in Trump era
  36. State Propaganda: Chinese media outlets hit with stricter rules while Fox churns out disinformation
  37. First week of staying at home: A window of images around Milwaukee for everyone stuck behind walls
  38. A Social Recession: The profound physical and psychological effects from long-term isolation
  39. An ego dripping in blood: Trump’s lies are killing Americans
  40. Obligations to each other: The pursuit of happiness is tied to the collective good
  41. Coronavirus and the Rule of Law: Courts struggle to preserve justice amid catastrophic conditions
  1. Milwaukee’s Holy Week observances canceled as public celebrations convert to at home video streaming
  2. Faith is not a Place: Church is a living body of people who gather in empathy, mercy, love, and justice
  3. St. Francis Seminary to provide shelter for residents with housing instability during COVID-19 crisis
  4. Millions of low-wage workers remain vulnerable to coronavirus due to lack of paid sick leave
  5. Milwaukee Hope: A hometown meme series designed to inspire optimism during the coronavirus crisis
  6. Dear America: I know how scared you are, I’m scared too
  7. Heroes of Hope: How to find healing and happiness when life is surrounded by havoc
  8. A Political Plan B: DNC organizers prepare contingency options for Milwaukee’s July Convention
  9. Coronavirus pours cold water on Olympic flame as Tokyo Games get postponed to 2021
  10. Milwaukee rolls out “drive-up” option for early voting to eliminate risk of COVID-19 exposure
  11. Hey, Milwaukee, you are not on vacation. Take the stay-at-home order seriously
  12. COVID-19 social media campaign launches in Milwaukee with best practices for staying healthy
  13. Coalition of Milwaukee philanthropies partner to coordinate local resources in response to COVID-19
  14. Fleeing the Coronavirus: The dangers for individuals and everyone they encounter along the journey
  15. Milwaukee County seeks donations of Personal Protective Equipment for COVID-19 frontline workers
  16. Medical gear from postponed charitable clinic to distributed first responders statewide
  17. The Great Apprehension: How to help kids relax as the pandemic upends everyday life
  18. The Myth of Youth: How children can be infected with coronavirus and transmit it to others
  19. Jonathan Brostoff: On COVID-19 and Wisconsin’s future “After the Storm”
  20. Reggie Jackson: The impact of racism is the “Other Coronavirus Crisis” for People of Color
  21. How to have a healthy conversation about the coronavirus with someone who is misinformed
  22. Mass transit in a time of need: MCTS to suspend fare collection for bus rides from March 28
  23. Fighting the Coronavirus: Why the U.S. military should deploy as a humanitarian aid force
  24. The Inconvenience of COVID-19: Understanding the shared national sacrifice for a greater good
  25. Kevin Abing: Milwaukee mobilized every resource possible in 1918 to combat the Spanish Flu epidemic
  26. Greatest Pandemic in History: Common misconceptions about the global influenza of 1918
  27. Month-long “Safer at Home” order urges Wisconsin residents to make sacrifices and work together
  28. Masks and the Microbe Menace: A misperception that safety measures shield risky activities from danger
  29. Not a Lockdown: Milwaukee implements “Stay At Home” directive in order to save lives
  30. Safer At Home: Wisconsin orders statewide closure of non-essential businesses to contain COVID-19
  31. Frontline nurses treating coronavirus victims condemn Trump’s racist rhetoric and cruelty
  32. PrideFest 2020 postponement due to COVID-19 foreshadows disruption of summer festival season
  33. Stop Touching Your Face: Changes to habitual behaviors can minimize the spread of COVID-19
  34. Reggie Jackson: The COVID-19 pandemic lays bare the absolute moral corruption of our society
  35. Health Official condemns Senator Ron Johnson’s false equivalency between traffic accidents and COVID-19
  36. The disappointment that comes when a pandemic cancels the freedom to party
  37. Vulnerable Populations: Infection rates and mortality from COVID-19 expected to hit the homeless hard
  38. Connecting without the human touch: How to cope with the side effects of social distancing
  39. Flattening the Curve: How to slow fear from spreading faster than COVID-19
  40. Sorry, We’re Closed: The signs and sights of solitude as Milwaukee digs in to fight COVID-19
  41. Being Positive during a Pandemic: 5 tips for getting through the coronavirus as a better person
  42. COVID-19 Mutual Aid: Confronting coronavirus conditions with community instead of consternation
  43. One of Wisconsin’s first two COVID-19 Deaths confirmed in Ozaukee County
  44. Price of our Pandemic: The bill for MAGA has come due and it is time to pay up
  45. The same people who believed COVID-19 was a hoax should now buy the homeopathic cure forsythia
  46. When plagues followed bad leadership: Greek tragedy of Oedipus Tyrannos is a lesson for Trump on COVID-19
  47. Wisconsin residents reminded to take precautions against COVID-19 scams and price gouging
  48. MCTS encourages riders to limit non-essential bus travel to help prevent spread of COVID-19
  49. The supply and demand of COVID-19: Predicted infection rates would overwhelm Milwaukee hospitals
  50. Wisconsin passengers under coronavirus quarantine aboard Grand Princess cruise ship return home safely
  51. Milwaukee Municipalities issue emergency orders closing bars and restaurants to protect public health
  52. Governor Tony Evers signs statewide order prohibiting mass gatherings of more than 50 People
  53. Teaching amid Coronavirus: What to expect from educational institutions as classes move online
  54. Wisconsin mandates closure of all K-12 Schools until early April to prevent spreading of COVID-19
  55. Closure of school cafeterias due to coronavirus puts poorest children at risk of missing nutritious meals
  56. Stop hoarding the Charmin: Why people are panic buying toilet paper when there is an abundant supply
  57. The social burden of Consumerism: Shopping carts are not overflowing with compassion
  58. Social Distancing: Think of it as “Elbow Room” for your health in the age of contagious pathogens
  59. City’s Health Department urges Milwaukee residents to avoid non-essential travel
  60. Milwaukee County Sheriff’s Office outlines COVID-19 protocols for protecting individuals in custody
  61. Coronavirus Hits Home: Milwaukee confirms first case of COVID-19 within the city
  62. Impact of COVID-19 sinks in for Milwaukee Bucks fans after NBA suspends remainder of season
  63. Governor Tony Evers declares public health emergency for Wisconsin in response to COVID-19
  64. A cauldron for infectious disease: Spread of COVID-19 inevitable in overcrowded ICE detention centers
  65. From SARS to Avian Influenza: A witness to history reflects on the first epidemics of the 21st-century
  66. Public health officials face challenges in distinguishing COVID-19 from seasonal influenza
  67. Plain old soap and water: Why hand-washing is still the best way to prevent illness
  68. Coronavirus Update: Milwaukee outlines preparations and precautions for dealing with COVID-19
For medical information, guidance, and resources, please visit the CDC’s COVID-19 information page or the Wisconsin Department of Health Services. All editorial content published by Milwaukee Independent related to the coronavirus can be found at mkeind.com/COVID19
Our mission of transformative journalism means that we are editorially independent. Our staff determines what is important news to report on, and in what voice to speak on issues. No one influences our opinion, and no one edits our editors. We are free from commercial bias and are not influenced by corporate interests, political affiliations, or a public preferences that rewards clicks with revenue. As an influential publication that provides Milwaukee with quality journalism, we depend on public support to fulfill our purpose. Our award-winning photojournalism, columns, interviews, and features have helped to achieve a range of positive social impact that enriches our community. Please join our effort by entrusting us with your contribution. Your Support Matters - Donate Now

About The Author

The Conversation

The Conversation US is a nonprofit media outlet, producing independent articles that are authored by academics and edited by professional. This feature is published under the terms of their Creative Commons license.