Select Page

Fear and Racism: Coronavirus is the latest disease to fuel mistrust of “the other”

By Korey Pasch, PhD Candidate in Political Science and International Relations, Queen’s University, Ontario

With the outbreak of the novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) in Wuhan, China, stories of courage and strength have captured our collective attention as the disease spreads.

We have also seen large-scale efforts in China to combat coronavirus, including the construction of new hospitals and facilities in provincial areas as well as the massive quarantine of millions of people. While efforts to address the disease move forward, the outbreak has also revealed the darker side of human nature and our responses to new diseases and other catastrophic events: mistrust, fear and outright racism.

Western countries have seen racism and stereotyping of the Chinese community as the number and location of cases of coronavirus have spread and fear of the outbreak festers. The surge of fear and racism in the face of this latest outbreak is similar to previous experiences in the wake of other diseases, such as the Ebola and Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) viruses.

Yet the prevalence of racism and scapegoating in the face of catastrophes and disasters has a much longer history than these more recent outbreaks. This history provides important context and is worth reflecting upon. It reminds us that disasters and catastrophes are not exclusively natural phenomena, and are also a result of the economic, political and social decisions that create vulnerability to risk.

Importantly, discrimination, racism and scapegoating has been used to distract from the underlying economic, political and social decisions that produced vulnerability to disaster and disease in the first place.

Disasters are not natural

While many headlines highlight “natural” disasters in the aftermath of the latest catastrophe, researchers in the field of disaster studies have long demonstrated the social construction of these events. This means that catastrophes, whether they’re the latest earthquake, hurricane or outbreak of disease like the coronavirus, are fundamentally connected to underlying factors that affect which areas and individuals are vulnerable and why.

Given these links, we must understand that there are specific interests, usually associated with the exercise of power, involved in how we view these connections or how we are distracted from them. In the case of the coronavirus, the recent death of Dr. Li Wenliang, who was censured by police over his early warnings about the disease, is an example of how power operates. He was reprimanded and silenced by the police in Wuhan and was forced to sign a letter saying he had made “false comments.”

It reminds us that accepting the relationship between economics, politics and the production of risk and vulnerability means that catastrophic events aren’t just natural phenomena — they are also political phenomena.

Tied into this political nature, disasters often result in people placing blame upon certain communities and groups for the event in question. This scapegoating diverts attention away from the underlying causes connected to economic, political and social decisions as well as the exercise of power.

Ebola fears

A similar epidemic of fear followed the 2014 outbreak of Ebola in West Africa, which resulted in the racist targeting of certain individuals and communities as the crisis worsened. This discrimination suggested there was no understanding of the Ebola outbreak within the larger history of the region.

Powerful global players, including the United States, the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, pushed various West African governments to adopt Structural Adjustment Programs (SAPs) to reduce deficits and make those states more attractive to investors and the global capital markets. In order to achieve this, SAPs required spending cuts to the health-care systems of those states, ultimately increasing the vulnerability of those populations to outbreaks of diseases like Ebola.

As with the current outbreak of 2019-nCoV in China, scapegoating and racist fear-mongering pointed the finger of blame at the Ebola victims themselves, not the underlying factors and decisions by the powerful that contributed to the crisis. The racism seen in the case of 2019-nCoV is just the latest example of how power is used to politicize and manipulate disasters.

Long history

Scapegoating, discrimination and victim-blaming have been prevalent in the aftermath of other catastrophic events. They are also related to religious or spiritual understandings of disasters and disease as divine retribution or punishment. Hurricane Katrina in 2005 resulted in various versions of this phenomenon. Many prominent conservative Christians blamed the hurricane on the LGBTQ+ community and the city’s “sinful” reputation.

The narratives surrounding Hurricane Katrina also reinforced racist stereotypes and tropes through media coverage on survivors based on their race: Black survivors were routinely characterized as “looting” in the aftermath of the storm, while white survivors were described as “finding supplies.”

This harmful and false narrative was hardly unprecedented. Going back even further, the Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923 led to racist pogroms, or massacres, against some 6,000 Koreans living in Japan due to rumors that they were setting fires that spread in the aftermath of the quake.

These Japanese-Korean tensions flared up decades later, in 2017, when Tokyo Governor Yuriko Koike refused to send the annual eulogy for victims of the pogroms, suggesting there was doubt that the massacres occurred.

Koike’s decision demonstrates how disasters and discrimination are tethered to the operation of power and control over how these events are understood, even a century later. Disasters clearly foment discrimination. And so we should expect these types of responses to future catastrophes and take proactive steps to address them.

Furthermore, we need to be mindful of how certain narratives and understandings of disasters act to distract us from far more important elements — including those that leave all of us vulnerable to disasters and disease.

Support evidence-based journalism with a tax-deductible donation today, make a contribution to The Conversation.

  1. Milwaukee Hope: A hometown meme series designed to inspire optimism during the coronavirus crisis
  2. Dear America: I know how scared you are, I’m scared too
  3. Heroes of Hope: How to find healing and happiness when life is surrounded by havoc
  4. A Political Plan B: DNC organizers prepare contingency options for Milwaukee’s July Convention
  5. Coronavirus pours cold water on Olympic flame as Tokyo Games get postponed to 2021
  6. Milwaukee rolls out “drive-up” option for early voting to eliminate risk of COVID-19 exposure
  7. Hey, Milwaukee, you are not on vacation. Take the stay-at-home order seriously
  8. COVID-19 social media campaign launches in Milwaukee with best practices for staying healthy
  9. Coalition of Milwaukee philanthropies partner to coordinate local resources in response to COVID-19
  10. Fleeing the Coronavirus: The dangers for individuals and everyone they encounter along the journey
  11. Milwaukee County seeks donations of Personal Protective Equipment for COVID-19 frontline workers
  12. Medical gear from postponed charitable clinic to distributed first responders statewide
  13. The Great Apprehension: How to help kids relax as the pandemic upends everyday life
  14. The Myth of Youth: How children can be infected with coronavirus and transmit it to others
  15. Jonathan Brostoff: On COVID-19 and Wisconsin’s future “After the Storm”
  16. Reggie Jackson: The impact of racism is the “Other Coronavirus Crisis” for People of Color
  17. How to have a healthy conversation about the coronavirus with someone who is misinformed
  18. Mass transit in a time of need: MCTS to suspend fare collection for bus rides from March 28
  19. Fighting the Coronavirus: Why the U.S. military should deploy as a humanitarian aid force
  20. The Inconvenience of COVID-19: Understanding the shared national sacrifice for a greater good
  21. Kevin Abing: Milwaukee mobilized every resource possible in 1918 to combat the Spanish Flu epidemic
  22. Greatest Pandemic in History: Common misconceptions about the global influenza of 1918
  23. Month-long “Safer at Home” order urges Wisconsin residents to make sacrifices and work together
  24. Masks and the Microbe Menace: A misperception that safety measures shield risky activities from danger
  25. Not a Lockdown: Milwaukee implements “Stay At Home” directive in order to save lives
  26. Safer At Home: Wisconsin orders statewide closure of non-essential businesses to contain COVID-19
  27. Frontline nurses treating coronavirus victims condemn Trump’s racist rhetoric and cruelty
  28. PrideFest 2020 postponement due to COVID-19 foreshadows disruption of summer festival season
  29. Reggie Jackson: The COVID-19 pandemic lays bare the absolute moral corruption of our society
  30. Health Official condemns Senator Ron Johnson’s false equivalency between traffic accidents and COVID-19
  31. The disappointment that comes when a pandemic cancels the freedom to party
  32. Vulnerable Populations: Infection rates and mortality from COVID-19 expected to hit the homeless hard
  33. Connecting without the human touch: How to cope with the side effects of social distancing
  34. Flattening the Curve: How to slow fear from spreading faster than COVID-19
  35. Sorry, We’re Closed: The signs and sights of solitude as Milwaukee digs in to fight COVID-19
  36. Being Positive during a Pandemic: 5 tips for getting through the coronavirus as a better person
  37. COVID-19 Mutual Aid: Confronting coronavirus conditions with community instead of consternation
  38. One of Wisconsin’s first two COVID-19 Deaths confirmed in Ozaukee County
  39. Price of our Pandemic: The bill for MAGA has come due and it is time to pay up
  40. The same people who believed COVID-19 was a hoax should now buy the homeopathic cure forsythia
  41. When plagues followed bad leadership: Greek tragedy of Oedipus Tyrannos is a lesson for Trump on COVID-19
  42. Wisconsin residents reminded to take precautions against COVID-19 scams and price gouging
  43. MCTS encourages riders to limit non-essential bus travel to help prevent spread of COVID-19
  44. The supply and demand of COVID-19: Predicted infection rates would overwhelm Milwaukee hospitals
  45. Wisconsin passengers under coronavirus quarantine aboard Grand Princess cruise ship return home safely
  46. Milwaukee Municipalities issue emergency orders closing bars and restaurants to protect public health
  47. Governor Tony Evers signs statewide order prohibiting mass gatherings of more than 50 People
  48. Teaching amid Coronavirus: What to expect from educational institutions as classes move online
  49. Wisconsin mandates closure of all K-12 Schools until early April to prevent spreading of COVID-19
  50. Closure of school cafeterias due to coronavirus puts poorest children at risk of missing nutritious meals
  51. Stop hoarding the Charmin: Why people are panic buying toilet paper when there is an abundant supply
  52. The social burden of Consumerism: Shopping carts are not overflowing with compassion
  53. Social Distancing: Think of it as “Elbow Room” for your health in the age of contagious pathogens
  54. City’s Health Department urges Milwaukee residents to avoid non-essential travel
  55. Milwaukee County Sheriff’s Office outlines COVID-19 protocols for protecting individuals in custody
  56. Coronavirus Hits Home: Milwaukee confirms first case of COVID-19 within the city
  57. Impact of COVID-19 sinks in for Milwaukee Bucks fans after NBA suspends remainder of season
  58. Governor Tony Evers declares public health emergency for Wisconsin in response to COVID-19
  59. A cauldron for infectious disease: Spread of COVID-19 inevitable in overcrowded ICE detention centers
  60. From SARS to Avian Influenza: A witness to history reflects on the first epidemics of the 21st-century
  61. Public health officials face challenges in distinguishing COVID-19 from seasonal influenza
  62. Plain old soap and water: Why hand-washing is still the best way to prevent illness
  63. Coronavirus Update: Milwaukee outlines preparations and precautions for dealing with COVID-19
For medical information, guidance, and resources, please visit the CDC’s COVID-19 information page or the Wisconsin Department of Health Services. All editorial content published by Milwaukee Independent related to the coronavirus can be found at mkeind.com/COVID19
Our mission of transformative journalism means that we are editorially independent. Our staff determines what is important news to report on, and in what voice to speak on issues. No one influences our opinion, and no one edits our editors. We are free from commercial bias and are not influenced by corporate interests, political affiliations, or a public preferences that rewards clicks with revenue. As an influential publication that provides Milwaukee with quality journalism, we depend on public support to fulfill our purpose. Our award-winning photojournalism, columns, interviews, and features have helped to achieve a range of positive social impact that enriches our community. Please join our effort by entrusting us with your contribution. Your Support Matters - Donate Now

About The Author

The Conversation

The Conversation US is a nonprofit media outlet, producing independent articles that are authored by academics and edited by professional. This feature is published under the terms of their Creative Commons license.