There was a time when the moral compass of American society pointed, however imperfectly, toward justice. Atrocities abroad and injustice at home would evoke outrage, public pressure, and political consequences.
For all the contradictions and hypocrisies in American history, there was once a basic expectation that when something terrible happened, people would care. Communities would rally, leaders would speak, and the faithful would act.
That assumption no longer holds true.
We live in an era where horror can unfold in real time. It is broadcasted, documented, and undeniable. The dominant reaction is not one of compassion or urgency, but of indifference.
Or worse: a studied cruelty that blames victims for their own suffering. It is not just that America’s faith is fractured or American society is divided. It is that both have been hollowed out and corrupted.
The rules have changed.
Social media is littered with viral posts showing unspeakable tragedies: children pulled from rubble, protesters brutalized, migrants turned away from safety. These posts are usually accompanied by a desperate plea like “Look at this. How can you not care?”
It is as if the sheer visibility should be enough to move hearts. But those appeals increasingly land in the void.
The truth is devastating: reason and basic decency are no longer persuasive. Logic, empathy, and facts — none penetrate the ideological armor of a movement that has replaced humanity with dogma.
To call this desensitization is to understate it. A vast swath of Americans have not simply become numb to cruelty — they have come to endorse it, actively or passively. Fueled by Trump’s ascendant movement, they see torment not as a consequence to be mourned, but as a strategy to be celebrated.
This is not a misunderstanding of policies or a disagreement over priorities. This is a deliberate embrace of hate, dressed in the language of patriotism and enforced through a theocratic, White Nationalist worldview.
It is no coincidence that those who cheer America’s sharp rightward turn are often the same people who once championed “law and order,” who claimed to revere the Constitution and the institutions it built.
Now, as Trump gleefully dismantles those very pillars by shredding democratic norms, weaponizing the executive branch, and openly mocking the rule of law — they applaud. What was once described as the silent majority has become the gleeful minority, loud in their triumph and utterly blind to the ruin it will inevitably bring.
The tragedy is not that these Americans have been lied to. The tragedy is that they chose to believe the lies, even when the truth was self-evident. They believed a conman who promised a revival of White power and McCarthy-era prosperity, when in reality he offered only division and decline. They voted for him once, then again.
And when democracy failed to validate their delusions, they demanded it be broken further. Their motivation was not national recovery. It was vengeance. They wanted retribution against imagined enemies like immigrants, liberals, journalists, professors, scientists, and even neighbors. They wrapped this in the flag, convinced themselves that cruelty was a virtue, and called it Making America Great Again.
Americans were taught to admire protectors like firefighters, doctors, and astronauts. Figures who rescued, who built, who stood for something greater than themselves. No one raised a child to aspire to be a tyrant. No bedtime story praised the tormentor.
Yet somewhere along the way, a movement emerged that abandoned these shared ideals. Not gradually, not by accident — but openly, even proudly. They did not just vote for a man who dehumanized others. They cheered as he did it. Brutality, once unthinkable, became desirable. The villain was not defeated. He was elected.
And now, as that inhumanity is returned to them, as the monster they empowered begins to devour their own communities, they have nothing to say.
Where are the town halls filled with fury over rising costs? Where are the protests against ICE’s sweeping overreach, deporting not just undocumented migrants but even protected residents and European tourists caught in the dragnet without due process?
Where is the MAGA outrage now that the stock market reels from tariffs so amateurishly designed that seasoned economists compared them to something a grade school child would have conjured with ChatGPT?
They are silent.
This same movement that flooded the streets to “stop the steal,” that bankrolled legal funds and rallies for election conspiracies, that screamed into cameras about their freedoms and faith, now stares blankly as the very nightmare they summoned becomes their lived reality. They are not victims of deception anymore. They are accomplices to collapse.
Efforts are still made to reach them with reason. Posts, podcasts, and editorials continue to appeal to their sense of fairness, their decency, and their supposed Christian values. But the moral reckoning needed here is not just about persuasion. It is about accountability. The people who supported Trumpism did not simply lose their way. They chose it with their eyes open, fists raised.
They watched the damage unfold and demanded more.
They cannot be reasoned with. They cannot be gently guided back to humanity. Because in backing a movement defined by exclusion, cruelty, and domination, they forfeited that humanity willingly. They screamed about the economy when it was the envy of the world. They blamed President Biden for mild inflation while ignoring what caused it, Trump’s COVID disaster and Putin’s war.
They voted for eggs. Cheaper eggs, they said. Then those eggs only became more expensive because Trump failed to fulfill his economic promises. And when inflation – which had actually been going down under President Biden – suddenly soared, when policies designed by ego rather than expertise torched global confidence, they said nothing. No reflection. No remorse. No change. And no demands.
What remains is not a silent majority but a complicit one. A bloc of Americans who have made clear, through action and inaction alike, that they are unmoved by suffering unless it is their own. They were not swayed by the caged children at the border, by the deaths in detention centers, and by the collapse of public trust or democratic norms.
Why would they be moved by atrocities abroad, when they celebrated them at home?
This is no longer about political disagreement. It is a spiritual crisis, one that reveals just how thin the line was between neighbor and oppressor. These are our co-workers. Our relatives. People who smile politely at barbecues, who sit beside us in pews or parent-teacher conferences. And yet, when given the chance to choose decency, they did not hesitate. They chose cruelty.
This betrayal of conscience did not happen overnight. It was cultivated over years by a propaganda machine that told Americans they were under siege — not from poverty or injustice, but from their fellow citizens.
Fox News, talk radio, and online echo chambers all cultivated a siege mentality, where White grievance was stoked, where every cultural shift was painted as a threat, and where losing privilege was framed as oppression.
The result is a civic rot so deep that even obvious self-destruction is applauded, as long as it punishes the “other” in the process. This is why ICE can sweep up the wrong people and conservatives cheer. Why new economic policies that actively damage the working class receive no backlash. Why civil liberties are stripped and called security measures. Because in this movement, pain is acceptable — so long as the “right” people suffer more.
And when that calculus backfires, when the damage spreads indiscriminately and they find themselves caught in the blast zone, they still refuse to blame the architects. They blame the media. They blame immigrants. They blame liberals. Everyone, except the man they worship and the movement they empowered.
The pattern is not new. History is replete with nations that sleepwalked into authoritarianism, ushered along not by iron-fisted rulers alone, but by average people who traded freedom for familiarity, democracy for dogma. Americans often ask how ordinary citizens in past atrocities like Nazis, Confederates, and colonizers justified their role in systems of suffering.
They need only look in the mirror.
It is not ignorance that defines this moment, but willful abdication of moral responsibility. To claim they “didn’t know” or were “just trying to help their family” is to rewrite reality. They knew. They were warned. They were shown the evidence. And they shrugged.
If that sounds harsh, it is because we are long past the point of comfort. A society cannot repair itself if it refuses to name its wounds. And the wound here is not merely Trump, or his toxic enablers in Congress. It is the neighbor who put up the sign. The friend who excused the cruelty. The church that said nothing. The voter who saw the chaos and said, “Yes, more.”
To excuse these choices is to normalize them. To treat them as simply a different worldview, as “economic anxiety” or “cultural alienation,” is to pretend that politics is just policy and not the expression of our deepest values. But it is precisely those values that have been laid bare and found wanting.
No one is owed redemption. It must be earned. And it cannot begin until the truth is spoken plainly: these Americans did not simply tolerate cruelty. They chose it. And they chose it not out of desperation or confusion, but because it aligned with what they had already come to believe — that their power was worth more than someone else’s humanity.
What comes next is uncertain. The institutions under assault will bend further and ultimately break. The Constitution, once treated as sacred, is now little more than a suggestion to those in power. The courts have been captured. Elections are undermined. Violence is no longer hypothetical — it is planned, praised, or even promised.
But clarity can still be salvaged. Those who have not yet surrendered to this nihilistic tide must stop pretending they can persuade it away. There is no unity without accountability. No compromise with cruelty. No reconciliation with lies.
It is time to act accordingly. Not to convince, but to confront. Not to plead, but to prepare. Because those who demanded this new America – one built on fear, repression, and the fiction of divine destiny — are no longer hiding. They are in power, and they are just getting started.
And the rest of us? We must stop waiting for them to care.
© Image
ChatGPT/Dall-E
